They called her difficult.
They called her untrainable.
By the time I met the small Arabian mare named Rosie, eight owners in eight years had already given up on her. The current owner was preparing to send her to auction — a fate that rarely ends well for a horse.
Somehow the grieving human and the troubled horse found each other.
What followed became a bond of trust that neither of us expected, but both of us needed.
Every horse person remembers their first ride.
Mine came at the age of twelve. Later, after transferring to a new job in Delaware, a colleague named Vivian convinced me to join her for riding lessons. She had recently attended the Devon Horse Show and concluded that riding must be simple — after all, the horse does most of the work.
We signed up for lessons at Arundel Stables in the middle of winter. The outdoor arena was buried in snow and the temperature hovered near twenty degrees.
Vivian rode a horse named Whitey. Each week she proudly mounted and rode toward the arena, only to have Whitey spin around and gallop back to the barn with Vivian screaming the entire way.
One especially cold morning Whitey decided he had endured enough. He deposited Vivian into a deep snow drift, cleared the arena fence, and returned to the warmth of his stall.
Vivian climbed out of the snow unleashing a series of colorful words before storming away.
It was the last day she ever rode a horse.
For reasons I still cannot fully explain, it was the day I realized riding had entered my blood.
Years later, I found the horse who would become my first great partner.
Her name was Sunshine.
She was a ten-year-old Arabian-Quarter Horse cross with kind eyes and endless energy. For the next twenty-five years we explored trails together, first on the East Coast and later in Arizona, where I moved with her when she turned twenty.
Sunshine lived to the remarkable age of thirty-five before impaction colic finally claimed her life.
Losing her was devastating. Some days I laughed remembering our adventures. Other days I cried buckets.
Her photographs still hang near the entryway of my home. Every time I walk through the door, she greets me.
I told myself I would never love another horse the same way.
Then Rosie appeared.
I was looking for a companion horse for Sunshine when someone suggested I visit a backyard outside of Phoenix to see an eight-year-old mare.
Rosie possessed none of the qualities I thought I wanted. She was defensive, mistrustful, and widely considered untrainable. Eight previous owners had passed her along like an unwanted responsibility.
The current owner was ready to send her to auction.
I bought her simply to spare her that fate.
I knew she would be a project. What I didn’t know was how deeply our lives would intertwine.
Training Rosie required help from an extraordinary horsewoman named Koelle.
Koelle quickly recognized that Rosie’s behavior wasn’t stubbornness — it was fear. Every interaction with humans triggered defensive reactions, particularly when anyone tried to touch her face or feet.
Years of mishandling had taught Rosie that people could not be trusted.
The first breakthrough came with the farrier. After a disastrous initial visit, he refused to work on Rosie again unless she was sedated.
Eventually I convinced him to attend a training session with Koelle.
He arrived skeptical.
Within an hour, Rosie stood quietly for hoof care and lifted her feet on cue without even being touched.
The farrier left astonished and still tells the story of Rosie’s transformation that day.
That was the moment the light bulb went on.
Rosie was not untrainable.
She simply needed someone willing to listen.
Despite her mistrust of humans, Rosie displayed surprising gentleness toward Sunshine as the older horse aged.
During turnout in the arena, Rosie adjusted her pace to match Sunshine’s ability on any given day. Some days they ran together. Other days Rosie simply circled protectively while Sunshine rested or struggled to stand after rolling in the sand.
Watching Rosie care for the older mare revealed a side of her few humans had ever seen.
Beneath her defenses was a remarkably intuitive horse.
One moment convinced me just how aware she truly was.
I turned Rosie loose in the arena to run. I removed my sunglasses so she could see my eyes more clearly while we worked together.
Afterward I walked toward the gate with Rosie following behind me.
Only when I reached the gate did I realize my prescription sunglasses were gone.
For twenty minutes I searched the entire arena, convinced they had been crushed beneath pounding hooves.
Rosie waited patiently at the gate, watching my every movement.
Finally, I gave up and walked back toward her.
At that exact moment Rosie left the gate, walked across the arena, and stopped in an unusual spot. She lowered her nose to the sand and held it there.
When I reached down to attach her lead rope, I saw them.
My sunglasses were lying directly beneath her nose.
Not only had she seen them fall — she had carefully avoided stepping on them while galloping around the arena.
When I put the glasses back on, Rosie rested her head on my shoulder and gently nuzzled my neck.
It was the first true affection she had ever offered.
No words were necessary.
Over time, Rosie allowed me to touch her face and welcomed the affection she once rejected.
Every day I remain grateful for the lessons she has taught me about patience, trust, and the quiet power of understanding.
They called her difficult.
They called her untrainable.
But Rosie simply needed someone willing to listen.
She lived with me for twenty years after that first uncertain meeting, and in time she became the horse no one believed she could be — calm, trusting, and deeply intuitive.
I lost Rosie in September of 2024.
Even now, when I walk into a barn and hear the soft shuffle of hooves, I still expect to see her dark eyes watching me.
Some horses teach us how to ride.
Rosie taught me how to listen.
Part of the “Lessons from the Herd” series
© 2026 Romancing the Herd. All Rights Reserved
Romancing the Herd 